Cloture Rankings December 17, 2011

Congressional Session 1121 adjorned on 1/3/2012, 1122 convened 1/3/2012. To See the full list of Cloture legislation become a member of SenateReports.com

Cloture is the only procedure by which the Senate can vote to place a time limit on consideration of a bill or other matter, and thereby overcome a filibuster. Under the cloture rule (Rule XXII), the Senate may limit consideration of a pending matter to 30 additional hours, but only by vote of three-fifths of the full Senate, normally 60 votes. Cloture is used by the Majority Party as a means to justify the end of debate and since the Majority Party dictates what legislation gets to the floor of the Senate in a timely manner it is usually in the best interest of Majority Party politics to vote for cloture to move the Leadership’s legislation along for a final vote. The Minority Party usually ‘rejects’ cloture to continue debating the legislation on the floor or to introduce ‘Table’ Amendments to promote their agendum.

Cloture Ranking List
Last Name First Name State Party Yeas Cloture Percent Rank
Franken Al Minnesota Democratic 33 34 97% 1
Hagan Kay North Carolina Democratic 33 34 97% 1
Manchin Joe West Virginia Democratic 33 34 97% 1
Bennet Michael Colorado Democratic 32 34 94% 2
Carper Thomas Delaware Democratic 32 34 94% 2
Coons Christopher Delaware Democratic 32 34 94% 2
Feinstein Dianne California Democratic 32 34 94% 2
Gillibrand Kirsten New York Democratic 32 34 94% 2
Klobuchar Amy Minnesota Democratic 32 34 94% 2
Kohl Herbert Wisconsin Democratic 32 34 94% 2
Lautenberg Frank New Jersey Democratic 32 34 94% 2
Levin Carl Michigan Democratic 32 34 94% 2
Menendez Robert New Jersey Democratic 32 34 94% 2
Nelson Bill Florida Democratic 32 34 94% 2
Reed Jack Rhode Island Democratic 32 34 94% 2
Warner Mark Virginia Democratic 32 34 94% 2
Bingaman Jeff New Mexico Democratic 31 34 91% 3
Blumenthal Richard Connecticut Democratic 31 34 91% 3
Boxer Barbara California Democratic 31 34 91% 3
Cardin Benjamin Maryland Democratic 31 34 91% 3
Casey Robert Pennsylvania Democratic 31 34 91% 3
Conrad Kent North Dakota Democratic 31 34 91% 3
Durbin Richard Illinois Democratic 31 34 91% 3
Johnson Tim South Dakota Democratic 31 34 91% 3
Lieberman Joseph Connecticut Independent 31 34 91% 3
Schumer Charles New York Democratic 31 34 91% 3
Shaheen Jeanne New Hampshire Democratic 31 34 91% 3
Udall Tom New Mexico Democratic 31 34 91% 3
Udall Mark Colorado Democratic 31 34 91% 3
Whitehouse Sheldon Rhode Island Democratic 31 34 91% 3
Akaka Daniel Hawaii Democratic 30 34 88% 4
Begich Mark Alaska Democratic 30 34 88% 4
Brown Sherrod Ohio Democratic 30 34 88% 4
Harkin Tom Iowa Democratic 30 34 88% 4
Inouye Daniel Hawaii Democratic 30 34 88% 4
Kerry John Massachusetts Democratic 30 34 88% 4
Landrieu Mary Louisiana Democratic 30 34 88% 4
Mikulski Barbara Maryland Democratic 30 34 88% 4
Murray Patty Washington Democratic 30 34 88% 4
Stabenow Debbie Michigan Democratic 30 34 88% 4
Tester Jon Montana Democratic 30 34 88% 4
Webb James Virginia Democratic 30 34 88% 4
Leahy Patrick Vermont Democratic 29 34 85% 5
Pryor Mark Arkansas Democratic 29 34 85% 5
Rockefeller Jay West Virginia Democratic 29 34 85% 5
Cantwell Maria Washington Democratic 28 34 82% 6
McCaskill Claire Missouri Democratic 28 34 82% 6
Reid Harry Nevada Democratic 28 34 82% 6
Baucus Max Montana Democratic 27 34 79% 7
Merkley Jeff Oregon Democratic 27 34 79% 7
Wyden Ron Oregon Democratic 27 34 79% 7
Sanders Bernard Vermont Independent 26 34 76% 8
Nelson Ben Nebraska Democratic 25 34 74% 9
Brown Scott Massachusetts Republican 25 34 74% 9
Collins Susan Maine Republican 24 34 71% 10
Snowe Olympia Maine Republican 23 34 68% 11
Alexander Lamar Tennessee Republican 18 34 53% 12
Hoeven John North Dakota Republican 18 34 53% 12
Graham Lindsey South Carolina Republican 17 34 50% 13
Hutchison Kay Texas Republican 17 34 50% 13
Isakson Johnny Georgia Republican 17 34 50% 13
Lugar Richard Indiana Republican 17 34 50% 13
McConnell Mitch Kentucky Republican 17 34 50% 13
Murkowski Lisa Alaska Republican 17 34 50% 13
Thune John South Dakota Republican 17 34 50% 13
Chambliss Saxby Georgia Republican 16 34 47% 14
Coats Dan Indiana Republican 16 34 47% 14
Cochran Thad Mississippi Republican 16 34 47% 14
Portman Robert Ohio Republican 16 34 47% 14
Shelby Richard Alabama Republican 16 34 47% 14
Ayotte Kelly New Hampshire Republican 15 34 44% 15
Barrasso John Wyoming Republican 15 34 44% 15
Blunt Roy Missouri Republican 15 34 44% 15
Boozman John Arkansas Republican 15 34 44% 15
Enzi Micheal Wyoming Republican 15 34 44% 15
Johanns Mike Nebraska Republican 15 34 44% 15
Kirk Mark Illinois Republican 15 34 44% 15
Kyl Jon Arizona Republican 15 34 44% 15
McCain John Arizona Republican 15 34 44% 15
Moran Jerry Kansas Republican 15 34 44% 15
Burr Richard North Carolina Republican 14 34 41% 16
Grassley Charles Iowa Republican 14 34 41% 16
Roberts Pat Kansas Republican 14 34 41% 16
Wicker Roger Mississippi Republican 14 34 41% 16
Sessions Jeff Alabama Republican 13 34 38% 17
Toomey Pat Pennsylvania Republican 13 34 38% 17
Corker Bob Tennessee Republican 12 34 35% 17
Cornyn John Texas Republican 12 34 35% 17
Hatch Orrin Utah Republican 12 34 35% 17
Inhofe James Oklahoma Republican 12 34 35% 17
Heller Dean Nevada Republican 10 29 34% 18
Crapo Mike Idaho Republican 10 34 29% 19
Vitter David Louisiana Republican 10 34 29% 19
Coburn Tom Oklahoma Republican 9 34 26% 20
Johnson Ron Wisconsin Republican 9 34 26% 20
Risch Jim Idaho Republican 8 34 24% 21
Rubio Marco Florida Republican 7 34 21% 22
DeMint Jim South Carolina Republican 5 34 15% 23
Lee Mike Utah Republican 4 34 12% 24
Paul Rand Kentucky Republican 3 34 9% 25

To qualify for a Cloture Ranking or any SenateReports.com ranking a Senator must have voted on at least 50% of the 235 roll call votes during the ranking session of the 112th 1st Congress. The following Senator did not qualify for a SenateReports.com ranking.

Last Name First NameStatePartySenate Votes
Ensign John Nevada Republican 63

John Eric Ensign (born March 25, 1958) is the former United States Senator from Nevada, serving from January 2001 until he resigned amid an investigation of an ethics violation in May 2011. He is a member of the Republican Party and the former chairman of the Senate Republican Policy Committee. Senator Dean Heller was appointed by the Nevada State Governor to fill the vacant Senate position until the 2012 elections.

Senator Harry Reid Majority Leader Harry Reid Democrat, Nevada
Senator Reid in ranked 6th (82%) on the Cloture Rankings List, he managed to get 29 of his 53 Democrats to vote on cloture 90% of the time or above in 2011. In 2010 54 of 59 Democratic Senators voted on cloture 90% of the time or greater in support of his Democratic Leadership. Democratic Senator Ben Nelson and Republican Senator Scott Brown are tied with a 9th ranking of 74%. Senator Brown is the top Republican Senator voting with the Democratic Leadership on 'Cloture'. Republican Senator Susan Collins is ranked at 10th (71%) while her fellow Maine Seantor Olympia Snowe is at 68% ranked 11th.  There are 5 Republican Senators voting over 50% of the time with the Democratic Leadership on Cloture.  At times having Republican Senators voting over 50% on cloture votes is like having extra Democrats supporting Senator Harry Reid's Democratic leadership, legislation and agenda.

Senator Harry Reid’s leadership is responsible for 25 of 43 (58%) successful pieces of Democratic Party legislation, of which 4 Bills were passed and 8 Progressive Judges confirmed without the support of the Republican majority of votes.

Assistant Majority Leader (Democratic Whip) Richard Durbin, Illinois is mainly responible for assisting the Majority Leader in his duties to carry out the legislation program of the Senate. Senator Durbin's leadership position has made him one of the most influential progressive democrats in the Senate. Go the Democratic Party Home Page. Review Senator Richard Durbin's Bio. Review Senate Committee Assignments. Go to Senator Durbin's Home Page. Senator Durbin is tied with 14 other Democratic Senators at 3rd (91%) place on the Cloture Ranking List this year, last year he was tied for 3rd place with 14 other Democrats with 96% and in 2009 he had a 97% Cloture Ranking Percentage.  Ever since the Democrats took control of the Senate in 2007 Senator Durbin's Cloture Percent has never lower than 92%. When the Republicans controlled the Senate between 2005 -2006 Senator Durbin maintained Cloture Percentages of 35% and 51% in support of the Republican leadership in the Senate. 

Senator Durbin has been an outstanding progressive democrat since 2005 as the 'Progressive Voting Percentage' table demonstrates. Since 2005 Senator Durbin has only voted for 6 of 491 (1%) pieces of Conservative Legislation, legislation that had no support from the Democratic majority of rollcall votes.

Progressive Voting Percentage
LastName Year Percent
Durbin 2005 98%
Obama 2005 97%
Lieberman 2005 88%
Durbin 2006 100%
Obama 2006 100%
Lieberman 2006 91%
Durbin 2007 98%
Lieberman 2007 79%
Durbin 2008 100%
Lieberman 2008 75%
Durbin 2009 100%
Lieberman 2009 91%
Durbin 2010 99%
Lieberman 2010 87%
Durbin 2011 96%
Lieberman 2011 63%

To most progressive and very liberal democrats Senator Joseph Lieberman has been a thorn in the Democratic Party ever since he ran as an 'Independent' and supported John McCain for President in 2008. These stout ideologues refuse to review Senator Lieberman's overall voting record since 2005 objectively, instead they judge him soley on one or two issues. Political dogma most of the time can't stand up to common sense or logic.

Since 2005 Senator Lieberman has voted with the Democratic Party Majority 84% of the time, the Democratic Party Majority's Party Percent Average over seven years has been 88%. IRAQ has been one of the key issues where Senator Lieberman has been at odds with the Democratic Party Leadership, Lieberman has voted 38 of 55 (69%) times against his Party's Majority since 2005 on key legislation concerning IRAQ.

Senator Lieberman has voted with Progressive roll call votes 74% of the time since 2005, not even close to hard core progressives like Senators Barbara Boxer, Sherrod Brown, Richard Durbin, Al Franken, Kirsten Gillibrand, Charles Schumer, and democratic socialist Bernard Sanders that have progressive ranking percentages in the high 90's.  Senator Joseph Lieberman

 

 

The last three years at least 48 Democrats have had Progessive Ranking Percentages at or above 90%, Senator Majority Leader Harry Reid from Nevada has a 87% Progressive Ranking Percentage, averaged over 7 years since 2005. Senator Reid's worst year voting with Progressive roll call votes determined by the Democratic Majority was in 2008 when he voted 75% of the time on key progressive roll call votes, the same year Senator Lieberman voted 75%.  But when 38 of 57 Democratic Senators are voting with their Party's Majority 90% of the time or greater, Senator's Lieberman's 83% Party Percent Average makes him look more like a moderate democrat than a progressive. This is the last year of Senator Lieberman's fourth and final term in the Senate.

Go to Senator Liberman's Home Page. Review Senator Joseph Lieberman's Bio. Review Senate Committee Assignments. Go to the Democratic Party Home Page.

In 2009 there were 11 Bills passed by the Democratic Majority that did not have any Republican majority of votes or support. Since 2009 there have been 25 of 58 (43%) Bills signed into law by President H. Obama that did not have any Republican majority support, a record number of partisan Bills since 2005 but still counting. From 2005 to 2008 under GWB 21 of 49 (43%) Bills were passed without any Democratic majority support.

Senator Mitch McConnell Minority Leader Mitch McConnell Republican, Kentucky 
Due to the lack of Republican partisan support and very little Democratic support Senator McConnell only managed to get 8 of 69 (12%) successful pieces of legislation thru the Democratic controlled Senate this year, that's half of last year's stats. Worse Senator McConnell has only been able to one Republican sponsored Bill passed thru the Democratic controlled Senate without the support of the Democratic majority of votes, H.R.3078 the United States-Colombia Trade Promotion Agreement Implementation Act sponsored by House Republican Eric Cantor. H.R.3078 has been the only Bill President Obama has signed into Law the Democratic Majority in the Senate had refused to support. Senator McConnell has sponsored 15 pieces of legislation since 2005, 8 were approved and 2 were signed into public law by George W. Bush S.3930 the Military Commissions Act of 2006 and S.1927 the Protect America Act of 2007. Under the Democrat controlled Senate Senator McConnell has only 5 pieces of sponsored legislation, only one has been approved S.Amdt.1136; an Amendment to limit the release of detainees at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba, pending a report on the prisoner population at the detention facility at Guantanamo Bay. By Contrast Senator Harry Reid had 5 of 15 pieces of sponsored legislation while President George W. Bush was in office, he had 10 pieces of sponsored legislation that made it to the floor of the Senate, 7 were approved, and none were signed into pubic law while President Obama has been in the White House. But one piece S.Res.159; a resolution honoring the members of the military and intelligence community who carried out the mission that killed Osama bin Laden is note worthy.

Senator McConnell is voting 17 of 34 (50%) on cloture votes with the Democratic leadership and is ranked number 13th in support of the Democratic leadership, 12 of his fellow Republican Senators have been voting with that leadership 50% of the time or greater last yearin 2011. Not something to brag about...for sure...but the winner and defender of the Constitution is no doubt Senator Rand Paul of Kentucky who voted only 3 of 34 (9%) times with the Democratic leadership on cloture roll call votes and is ranked at the bottom of the Cloture Ranking List with a 25 ranking.

Please leave a question, comment, suggestion or random thought about your visit at SenateReports.com on the Contact page.